Featuring interventions from early childhood to adulthood, from tax changes to the introduction of job coaches, from the promotion of ‘basic life skills’ among five-year-olds to bringing ‘work skills’ into the school curriculum, a doubling of young apprentices and a legal guarantee of support, the Milburn report presents a total reset for young people and early career management in the UK.
The HR World's Expert Panel on Skills and Education will be giving their response to Alan Milburn's Report in due course.
Update: 15:00 17/11/26
Reaction to the Milburn Report has been extensive, reflecting the far reach of his recommendations and the emotive issue it seeks to address. While many are welcoming the proposals and everyone agrees something must be done, it is no surprise to find there is no ‘easy fix’ here, moreover, there are further implications for needed change and improvement in other parts of the employment cycle if the situation is to be in any way resolved.
Niki Turner-Harding, Senior Vice President & Country Head at Adecco Group warns that AI could make it even harder for the next generation to get a foot on the career ladder. As a result she advises that businesses should redesign junior roles rather than eliminate them. "AI has the potential to level the playing field, but it could just as easily tip it further,” she says. “As technology takes on more of the routine tasks that previous generations traditionally learned on, we risk removing the very opportunities they need to develop their skills, judgement and experience.
"The answer cannot be to simply cut junior roles in the pursuit of short-term efficiencies,” she adds. "If AI is changing the nature of entry-level work, those roles need redesigning, not deleting. Businesses need to invest in the next generation, because the decisions businesses make about junior roles today will determine who is capable of leading them in the coming years.”
An inclusive approach
“We need wholesale change, with disability inclusion at the centre,” says Diane Lightfoot, Chief Executive of Business Disability Forum. “We are pleased to see this acknowledged by Alan Milburn and his team in their review today. Their recommendations for creating an integrated system which brings together welfare, education and health offers an inclusive approach to reform that we believe could not only be transformative for young people but could also benefit everyone, across all age groups. This includes young disabled adults, 25 and over, who have never had a first job, as well as older disabled workers looking return to the workplace.”
Ann Francke OBE, CEO of the Chartered Management Institute welcomes the reduction in costs for employers when hiring younger workers as well as the initiatives designed to create more jobs and training opportunities. “But getting young people through the door is only half the battle,” she says. “If we don't train the managers who are charged with looking after them once they arrive, we won't see benefits for either the young people or their employers.
“We know that only 6% of managers think young people have the skills to thrive in the workplace. So it's vital that we help young people develop skills like resilience, communication and the ability to build on feedback.
Francke’s reaction suggests another initiative on the cards for HR and L&D in particular: “It’s absolutely essential that we train the managers who are looking after them,” she says. “In fact, 80% of young workers say a trained manager is critical to building their confidence. This is how we'll unlock productivity for employers and progression for NEETs – by enabling these young people and their managers to work together to deliver on the organisation's agenda. Without that, this well-intentioned plan risks becoming a very expensive revolving door for taxpayers.”
Sally Neale, Chief People Officer, ArvatoConnect is clear that the situation cannot be blamed on those who are still without work: “It’s really frustrating to see employers saying young people lack work ethic, and young people saying employers are out of touch,” she says. “Employers have to rethink what a good first job looks like, with greater flexibility, development and support, rather than expecting young people simply to replicate the working lives of previous generations. But young people also need to challenge themselves more, build confidence and develop the skills that will help them succeed at work. As AI increasingly mediates workplace communication, we need to make sure we’re still teaching managers and young people how to have honest, sometimes difficult, human conversations.
Neale adds that if the Milburn Review is going to create lasting change, its only goal cannot be about getting more young people through the workplace door. “It has to be about government, education, employers and young people working together to make sure they can thrive once they are there.”
Is it worth it?
Finally, Dave Chaplin, CEO of contracting authority ContractorCalculator, is more scathing of the impact of the report’s measures: "The report forecasts that the recommendations, if implemented, will only reduce the NEET rate from 13.1% in 2026/27 to 10.1% in 2030/31,” he says. “The impact is too small and will take too long.
“Young people should not wait for government action to help them find employment in jobs they may not want to do. Instead, they should start their own business, working self-employed on a fixed priced project by project basis.
“The report demonstrates that Labour Government policies introduced too many barriers to hiring young people which aren't going to be resolved overnight,” he adds. “Working for oneself puts young people in control of their own careers right now, rather than waiting for policy to change.”
09:00 17/11/26
Faced with the daunting prospect of dealing with nearly one million young people not in education, employment or training, the government is faced not just with an immediate problem but one which will reverberate across generations and throughout the workplace for years to come if left unchecked.
But while the report can be admired for its scale and ambition, questions remain.
Firstly, and a little unfairly, perhaps, is this enough? Do the targets, laws, spending and initiatives outlined here add up to real, lasting change?
Secondly, does the current government have the confidence and control to implement the proposals in full? Burnham may have had a positive impact on the government, but is there the will to impact on welfare provision?
Third, what will be the impact of not implementing everything? If the government ends up cherry-picking the policies it likes and leaving the harder ones, will the reset happen at all? And aligned with that - what is going to happen while these initiatives and laws are introduced and take effect? This is a ten-year plan, the scale of this issue is not one that can be fixed or even addressed overnight. So what happens for those caught in the crisis now?
Simon Reichwald expert panel leader for The HR World for Skills and Education, and founder of UnTappedTalent highlights the fact that the balance of spend supporting young people certainly needs addressing, noting that for every £1 spent on helping young people get into work, £25 is spent on benefits while they are out of work. He also notes that in the lead up to report’s release today more fuss has been made over the removal of benefits rather than the shift to more taxpayer money being spent on enabling young people to get into work.
He also emphasises the need to ensure employers are able to contribute to the positive road ahead. “Key to reducing WEET (Want Employment, Education or Training) numbers, is not just about reducing the employment costs of hiring a young person, but also making it easier for an employer to navigate apprenticeships and provide work experience,” he says, “and having young people more ‘work ready’, so reducing the internal resource needed to onboard and develop this new talent, which is so often overlooked as part of the costs of hiring.”
Throughout today we will add to this news report, bringing reaction and discussion to Milburn’s vision for the future.
Send us your thoughts and comments on Milburn's strategy: Simon.kent@thehrworld.co.uk
More discussion on NEETs:




